There were many of the recipes I remembered fondly from my childhood... date-nut bread... thimble cookies... peanut butter cookies... Plus a whole host of cookies, cakes, muffins and treats I don't remember at all.
Having collected recipes on my own for several years already, I realized that many of my grandma's tried-and-trues have been around for years, published on the inside of butter boxes, on the back of baking soda boxes, on the sides of cans and bottles. On looking through some of her more unfamiliar recipes, I began to see some I recognized from old Betty Crocker cookbooks, and some torn pages of magazines that duplicated a couple of her hand-written ones.
In short, there are no secret heirloom family recipes here; just a conglomeration of her favorites from Pillsbury and Betty Crocker and Land O' Lakes. I felt a tiny twinge of disappointment at first, but soon I got over it. What makes a recipe a treasure after all is not where it came from, but the memories I have helping my grandmother measure, sift and pour; rolling little balls of dough in sugar or nuts; lining up dozens of finished cookies on tin foil sheets to cool; watching her pipe icing roses onto each cookie with a speed and precision I could never match.
A couple of recipes still fail me... As many recipes as I have tried for thimble or thumbprint cookies, I can never seem to get mine to match Grandma's... either they spread too much or are not the right texture. Same with her "butterballs"; the closest I have come to those are Mexican Wedding cookies and they are not the same either. And no one in the family has ever been able to match - or even for that matter spell her famous "chambalone". (It was actually her mother's, and I suspected it is somehow related to the italian pastry ciambela but again, I've never been able to pull it off like I remember it.)
Another thing I learned from my grandmother's cookbook is that while she may have been an awesome baker, she was, well, not so much a chef. There were a few specialties she made - homemade gnocchi was by far my favorite, something she made only rarely when family came to visit because it was such a fuss. On similar occasions she made polenta, which I never had a taste for as a kid; and homemade spaghetti sauce, which I also never appreciated, having been accustomed to thin, watery Ragu, which was red and smooth and never had any chunks of icky stuff in it. (Truth be told, however, I really preferred ketchup.)
However, her cookbook revealed a somewhat more "institutional" side to her cooking, and I mean that in the most 1970s school cafeteria way possible. (Remember she worked in a hospital kitchen then.) I was fully an adult before I could stomach broccoli, largely because of the memories of my grandmother cooking it. She would start it about three, when supper was at 5 or 6, and it would spend the entirety of those 2-3 hours boiling on the stove until even "gray and limp" were no longer adequate descriptors.
Grandma's main dish recipes are in the back of her cookbook, and start off innocuously with "Mushrooms and Chicken, Company Style" and "Minestrone Soup." You don't have to flip many pages though to find "Tunaburgers," "Party Tuna Pate" (please don't invite me to any party featuring tuna pate!) and "Meat Muffins." (I am not talking about famous - and delicious - meatloaf muffins, where you take a meatloaf mixture and bake it in muffin cups for individual portions... I am talking about regular baking-mix-and-milk muffins. Made with meat.) I'm guessing she raided an Oscar Mayer wrapper at some point because she also had a recipe for "Weiner Manicotti" and "Franks and Lentil Soup." And of course, at the very end of the book: "Clamburgers." Mmmmmmmm.
I had to toss the old plastic binder but I have carefully placed all Grandma's recipes into sheet protectors (including Clamburgers) and given them a home in a sturdy new red binder. It may take the rest of my life to perfect the thimble cookies the way I remember them. And I'm sure the rest of my life will be but a distant memory before Clamburgers are served from my kitchen. But hopefully that will be a discussion my grandchildren can have when they inherit my cookbooks.

No comments:
Post a Comment